More creative output leaves brand-building progress unproven

A larger creative budget can produce more ads while consumers see only a small selection. For marketing budget owners, production volume therefore measures one part of the work: what the team made. Media allocation shows which ads received funding and where they ran. Judging whether that activity strengthens a brand requires connecting production and distribution to outcomes.

CreativeX describes creators and Generative AI, AI that produces content, as marketing’s “two big bets” over the preceding two years, both promising faster, cheaper production at greater scale. The company also promotes an approach it calls Creative Observability, so it has a commercial interest in brands adopting it. Its analysis raises a practical investment question: as production expands, which work receives funding, what reaches viewers, and how does that exposure build a stronger brand?

CreativeX: Five assets receive 88% of the average campaign’s media spend

The connection between production and distribution starts with how campaign budgets are divided. In its analysis titled “DMWF Spotlight: What 9.2 million ads reveal about marketing’s biggest bets,” CreativeX examined 9.2 million ads across 115,990 campaigns, representing $11 billion in media spending. It found that five assets, or individual pieces of advertising creative, receive 88% of the media budget in the average campaign. A production count cannot show that concentration.

To examine this concentration, CreativeX looked at what brands produced, where ads ran, how spending was divided, and whether those decisions worked together to support effectiveness. Ranking individual ads by performance can identify stronger executions. Examining the campaign portfolio, the full collection of ads, shows how investment was distributed across the available work. Budget owners can then connect creative decisions with media decisions.

The connection matters when brands produce dozens or hundreds of executions, as CreativeX describes, but direct most funding toward a small selection. Spending and placement shape what consumers encounter, so the production inventory can overstate the range of work receiving substantial exposure. Spending distribution helps identify which ads received support, although it does not directly measure every consumer’s exposure. Individual campaigns may also have different allocation patterns from the average.

Within a campaign, limited support can matter especially for creative developed around a distinct message or audience. Producing an execution shows that the team developed the approach, but meaningful exposure also depends on media funding. Underfunded creative therefore raises a budget question; any claim that a particular demographic was excluded remains separate. Teams need to examine both the available approaches and the support each received.

Yet concentrating spending can be effective because a campaign may benefit from backing its strongest work. Equal funding is unnecessary, and the concentration figure alone does not establish a mistake. The useful question is whether the heavily funded selection serves the campaign’s objectives. Answering it requires visibility into the choices between production and distribution, followed by evidence of their outcomes.

Okoone experts
LET'S TALK!

A project in mind?
Schedule a 30-minute meeting with us.

Senior experts helping you move faster across product, engineering, cloud & AI.

Please enter a valid business email address.

More executions can still leave a portfolio with limited variety

Before assessing those funding choices, teams need to understand how much variety the production inventory contains. CreativeX reports that content production increased 30% over the last three years, while 47% of campaigns have a creative diversity score below 50%. These findings place rising output alongside limited variety across a substantial share of portfolios. They are separate observations, so they do not show that increased production caused the diversity result.

Additional executions can be closely related versions of an existing ad, which means a larger inventory may carry much the same message even as the number of finished ads rises. Reviewing the creative approaches within that inventory reveals whether production has added different ways to communicate with different audiences. The campaign-level diversity figure addresses this portfolio question; it does not measure a population excluded from advertising.

Variety also has a reported connection to viewing behavior: CreativeX found increased attention across Meta campaigns among brands that prioritized variety in production. Here, attention means people beginning to watch or otherwise attending to an ad. The association gives teams a reason to examine whether distinct approaches contribute to their objectives and receive enough support to assess their performance. Commercial returns remain a separate outcome to evaluate.

Creator ads attract more initial viewers but retain a smaller share

Viewing behavior needs to be separated into stages because attracting viewers and keeping them answer different questions. In CreativeX’s comparison on Meta, creator ads achieved a reported 2.4x advantage over brand ads in three-second view rate, with rates of 17% and 7%, respectively. A greater proportion of people reached that initial viewing threshold for creator ads. This establishes an advantage in attracting initial viewers.

The comparison shifts when CreativeX measures retention, meaning the share of those initial viewers who remain to a later point. At 15 seconds, 27% of the creator-ad viewers remained, compared with 40% of the brand-ad viewers. These percentages use the initial viewers as their denominator, whereas the three-second view rates measure the proportion reaching the earlier threshold. Brand ads therefore retained a larger share of the group they initially attracted.

For paid-creative decisions, the different denominators explain why both results matter: one measures initial attraction, while the other measures retention among people already watching. Neither alone establishes overall viewing duration, the absolute retained audience, or superior brand impact. Brand impact means what exposure changes for the advertiser, which requires evidence connecting viewing to an outcome for that brand.

Connecting viewing to outcomes becomes particularly important in CreativeX’s finding that $55M in media spending supported creator ads without branding. The spending makes branding presence a material question for campaign review, while the investment’s value still needs to be assessed through its outcomes. Teams need to determine how the engagement they purchase connects to the brand paying for it. An ad’s ability to attract viewers explains only part of that connection.

To examine how teams select such ads, CreativeX asks whether organic metrics, performance measures for unpaid content, may exert too much influence over paid-content decisions. This is a proposed explanation to investigate. If a team selects creative because it performs well organically, it still needs to establish how that performance serves a paid brand objective. Success in one setting provides a reason to test its value in the other.

Retention raises a related question about what advertisers receive from the exposure they buy. CreativeX asks whether an ad that keeps viewers longer could deliver more value for the advertiser. The proportional retention results make that a useful question, but a commercial comparison requires outcomes connected to the advertiser’s objective. Initial viewing, later retention, and branding presence each describe a different part of that connection.

Evaluate production, media allocation, and outcomes together

Connecting those measures is the purpose of CreativeX’s proposed Creative Observability approach: making the relationships among production, placement, spending, and performance visible as advertising becomes more complex. CreativeX presents it alongside continued consideration of creators, AI, and automated media buying, in which software makes media-purchasing decisions. The recommendation reflects the company’s commercial interest in the approach. It can accommodate concentrated spending when that allocation serves the campaign’s goals.

A practical review can follow the same sequence, starting with the work available for distribution. Creative and marketing-operations leads can separate genuinely different approaches from variations of the same execution, then connect that inventory to the media plan. They can then establish which ads received funding, how spending was divided, and where the ads ran. This turns a production total into a record of which creative choices received meaningful support.

With production and funding connected, the budget review can identify what each reported outcome establishes. A three-second view result supports a decision about initial attention; retention describes how well an ad keeps the viewers it attracted; branding presence establishes whether branding appears in the creative. Evidence of brand or commercial impact must connect exposure to a change for the advertiser. Keeping these measures distinct lets teams judge each result against the objective it can actually answer.

Key executive takeaways

  • Follow the media allocation: Five assets receive 88% of the average campaign’s media budget in CreativeX’s analysis. Budget owners need to assess whether the funded selection serves campaign objectives before expanding production.
  • Review creative variety: Production rose 30% over three years, while 47% of campaigns scored below 50% for creative diversity. Creative leads can review portfolios for distinct messages and audience approaches, then check which received meaningful media support.
  • Separate attraction from retention: Creator ads attracted more initial viewers on Meta, while brand ads retained a larger share of those viewers at 15 seconds. Paid-media owners need to evaluate each measure against campaign objectives and investigate how creator content connects attention to the paying brand.
  • Connect production to outcomes: Marketing-operations leads can link creative inventories, placements, spending, and performance in one review. Budget decisions then require evidence connecting exposure to brand or commercial outcomes, with views, retention, and branding presence treated as separate measures.

Alexander Procter

November 16, 2026

7 Min

Okoone experts
LET'S TALK!

A project in mind?
Schedule a 30-minute meeting with us.

Senior experts helping you move faster across product, engineering, cloud & AI.

Please enter a valid business email address.