Lead-quality disputes persist when teams disagree on what “better” means
Repeated changes to lead scoring can leave a business-to-business (B2B) marketing team facing the same dispute: sales wants more leads and remains unhappy with their quality. If salespeople disagree about which companies deserve attention, changing a score leaves the disagreement unresolved. Demand generation, the work of creating interest and opportunities among potential customers, needs a shared definition of suitability before it can consistently prioritize leads.
An unnamed marketer describes encountering this problem in a recent conversation at a local event. Another marketer had returned to an in-house role after working at an agency and faced sales requests for more leads alongside complaints about quality. The first marketer asks: “But what does “better” actually mean?” Marketing cannot act consistently when each salesperson expects something different.
Each expectation may have a reasonable basis. One salesperson values company size, another examines the technology environment, and a third considers strong interest enough reason to pursue an account. Without agreement, marketing delivers leads, sales challenges them, and marketing changes targeting or lead scoring, the system used to assign priority to prospects. An ideal customer profile, or ICP, gives those changes a common basis by defining which customer relationships the business wants to pursue.
A good-fit customer must be suitable beyond the sale
Defining those relationships starts with deciding which potential buyers the business can serve successfully. Total addressable market, or TAM, describes the full set of possible buyers; an ICP identifies the accounts the business is equipped to acquire and sustain. The marketer frames the decision as a question: “Of all the companies that could buy from you, which ones should you prioritize?”
Choosing among possible buyers requires looking beyond what makes a sale possible. A company may have the budget, operate in a relevant industry, and genuinely need the product, yet require difficult integrations or use technology that creates lasting obstacles. Experience with similar customers may also reveal problems with adoption, renewal, or expansion. These conditions affect whether winning the account will lead to a relationship the business can sustain.
The marketer recalls a former CEO who captured this longer view by asking: “Are we a good fit for the customer, and is the customer a good fit for us?” The CEO would decline revenue when implementation would be too difficult, support demands would be excessive, or the product would serve the customer poorly. Fit therefore spans acquisition, implementation, support, retention, and growth. An account with suitable requirements and room to expand may deserve priority over revenue the organization would struggle to support.
To make that decision, teams need more detail than a broad audience description provides. The segment “B2B SaaS companies using HubSpot” identifies companies that sell software as a service, software accessed online through a subscription, and an installed technology, but leaves purchase likelihood and post-sale suitability largely undecided. Companies within that segment can still have very different needs and delivery requirements. Marketing and sales need criteria that explain which companies deserve attention and why.
A project in mind?
Schedule a 30-minute meeting with us.
Senior experts helping you move faster across product, engineering, cloud & AI.
Define fit by product, then make it usable in your systems
Those criteria begin with characteristics that explain why one account warrants a different decision from another. Firmographics, the basic characteristics of a company, include industry, revenue, employee count, and operational scale. They help establish whether an account falls within the range a product is designed to serve. The company’s technology and working methods then show how the product would fit into its operations.
To understand those working methods, teams need to examine installed systems, competing products, internally developed alternatives, and work still performed manually. A purchase could replace an established system, displace an internal tool, or introduce software into a manual process. Each creates different adoption and implementation requirements. Integration needs, process complexity, and expected customization make those requirements more concrete and help teams assess the work needed to serve the account.
Delivery requirements also reveal reasons to deprioritize a company. These may include an unsupported geography, incompatible technology, customization beyond the delivery team’s capacity, or a company size the product serves poorly. An earlier opportunity may also have failed because the product lacked something fundamental. Recording these conditions gives marketing and sales a shared reason to withhold attention even when other attributes look promising.
Suitability also depends on which product the team wants to sell. In the marketer’s hypothetical example, one company is highly suitable for Product A, moderately suitable for Product B, and poorly suited to Product C. A company-wide score compresses those judgments into a single result, giving little guidance about which offer to discuss. Before adjusting scoring weights, teams should ask the marketer’s diagnostic question: “How strong is the fit for what we’re actually trying to sell?”
The marketer describes applying this approach earlier in their career at an unnamed business with “two very different products”. They helped create separate automated ICP scores in Salesforce so teams could assess suitability for each offering independently. The scores used company type and size, the technology environment, and reliance on a competing product or an internally built solution. They also incorporated previous opportunities and whether the company already purchased the other product.
Commercial history is useful only when teams preserve what it means. An existing customer may present a cross-sell opportunity, meaning a chance to sell another product, while an earlier loss caused by timing may leave a future sale open. A loss caused by a fundamental product limitation calls for a different suitability judgment. A field recording only whether an opportunity was lost would erase the distinction needed to make that judgment.
Beyond commercial history, customer-success experience can identify characteristics associated with adoption, retention, and expansion. Teams can use these characteristics to turn the broader definition of fit into fields and scores in customer relationship management, or CRM, and marketing systems. Account scoring applies the definition to a company; product-specific scoring evaluates its suitability for a particular offer. The marketer recommends product-level scoring wherever feasible so the data preserve the distinctions teams need when deciding what to promote and whom to pursue.
Interpret engagement through account and contact fit
Once teams can use fit in their systems, they can interpret activity in context. The marketer separates three questions: account fit asks, “Is this company a strong match for the product?”; contact fit asks, “Is this person relevant to the buying process?”; and engagement asks, “Are people within the account showing meaningful interest?” Each adds different information to a prioritization decision. Keeping them separate makes the reasoning visible.
Without that separation, individual activity can dominate a lead score. An ebook download, webinar attendance, or visit to a high-intent page can raise someone’s score while leaving the employer’s suitability unresolved. A highly active person may work at a company with incompatible technology or implementation requirements the business cannot support. So that individual can rank above a moderately engaged buying group at a company that closely matches the product’s requirements.
Buying-group activity may be spread among several contacts, so assessing it at account level can reveal interest that individual scores understate. Teams can then consider both the company’s suitability and the behavior of relevant people within it. Fit can also influence how much activity warrants investigation. In a marketing qualified account, or MQA, model, an account receives attention when its combined characteristics and behavior justify further consideration.
To illustrate that judgment, the marketer compares an ICP score of 90 with a score of 45. Moderate activity at the higher-scoring account might prompt investigation, while the same activity at the lower-scoring account might lead to continued nurturing. These are example values rather than prescribed thresholds. They show how equivalent behavior can lead to different decisions when the companies differ in suitability.
Investigation still needs to establish whether a conversation is timely, because strong fit alone does not establish buying readiness. An excellent prospective customer may show too little interest to justify sales outreach, even when the business could serve it well. Relevant contacts and meaningful activity help determine when further action makes sense. Keeping these judgments visible allows a team to recognize a suitable future customer and deliberately give it more time.
Carry the same fit criteria into audiences, handoffs, and spending
The criteria used to prioritize accounts can also determine which companies enter campaign audiences. In account-based marketing, or ABM, teams coordinate activity around selected companies. The marketer’s illustrative audience combines a Product A ICP score of “70 or higher” with a relevant target persona, a description of the person the campaign aims to reach, and a buying signal. Together, these conditions establish product suitability, contact relevance, and evidence that action may be timely.
Agreed conditions reduce the need to restart the audience debate for every campaign. Instead of repeatedly asking, “Are these the right accounts?”, teams can apply their product-fit criteria and concentrate on strategy, messaging, and timing. The marketer connects this approach to an earlier guide they wrote for small B2B marketing teams adopting ABM. Both recommendations begin with deciding which accounts merit pursuit before organizing campaigns around them.
When campaign activity warrants a sales handoff, the explanation should preserve the reasoning used to select the account. The marketer offers this hypothetical wording: “This is a strong-fit account for Product A, we’re seeing engagement from relevant contacts, and activity across the account is increasing.” It gives sales a product-specific rationale, explains why the people involved matter, and describes the direction of activity. An alert about an ebook download or a passed score threshold gives sales less information for judging the next step.
The marketer also references sales-alignment work involving ABM leaders at Snowflake, Datadog, and Unisys when discussing suitability and timing. In the marketer’s proposed framework, the handoff gives the receiving salesperson both judgments: why the company merits pursuit and what recent behavior prompted attention. Making both explicit gives the next conversation a clearer starting point. Sales can assess the immediate opportunity while retaining the account-selection rationale.
The same selection criteria can guide spending across paid media, events, content syndication, personalization, and other campaigns. For example, a team choosing an event audience or paid-media segment can apply the product-fit definition already used in account prioritization. As responses arrive, it can interpret engagement across each account. This connects the initial spending decision about whom to reach with the later decision about how much attention a response deserves.
Refine the ICP using sales and customer outcomes
Campaign and sales decisions put the profile into use; customer outcomes show where it needs revision. The marketer recommends that marketing, sales, and customer success regularly ask: “Which accounts convert and close?”, “Which implement successfully?”, “Which retain and expand?”, and “Which stall, churn, or require more support than expected?” These questions extend the review beyond acquisition to the work of delivering and maintaining the relationship.
Each function contributes evidence from a different stage of that relationship. Marketing can identify characteristics associated with engagement, sales can identify those associated with closing, and customer success can explain patterns in adoption, renewal, and expansion. Reviewing these observations together prevents success at one stage from defining the entire profile. An account that is easy to engage or close may still reveal delivery and retention problems that should influence future targeting.
As products, markets, and the customer base change, teams can use these observations to revise specific criteria. Recurring implementation difficulties may call for changes to an operational-fit criterion, while expansion among a particular customer type may suggest a characteristic worth investigating. Such patterns inform judgment without automatically explaining their causes. Once teams agree on a revision, they can update the relevant system fields and scoring rules so future audiences and account decisions reflect what they have learned.
Key executive takeaways
- Agree on customer fit: Marketing and sales need shared criteria for which companies deserve attention. Establish that definition before changing lead-scoring weights so revisions address agreed priorities.
- Assess the full customer relationship: Sales and customer success need to evaluate implementation demands, support requirements, retention prospects, and expansion potential alongside purchase likelihood. Use those findings to identify accounts the business can serve sustainably.
- Score fit by product: Marketing operations can build separate product-fit scores in CRM and marketing systems using company characteristics, technology, delivery requirements, and commercial history. This gives sales a clearer basis for choosing which offer to pursue.
- Separate fit from engagement: Account suitability, contact relevance, and buying activity answer different questions. Sales and marketing can assess them together to determine when activity warrants outreach, investigation, or continued nurturing.
- Carry shared criteria into execution: Campaign owners can use product-fit criteria to select audiences and allocate spending. Sales handoffs need to explain why the account fits, which relevant contacts are engaged, and what activity makes attention timely.
- Refine profiles using customer outcomes: Marketing, sales, and customer success need regular reviews of conversion, implementation, retention, expansion, and support demands. Translate agreed findings into updated criteria, system fields, and scoring rules.
A project in mind?
Schedule a 30-minute meeting with us.
Senior experts helping you move faster across product, engineering, cloud & AI.


