AI shifts marketers’ work toward decisions

Producing marketing content with less manual effort leaves marketers responsible for deciding whether it deserves an audience. AI can handle production tasks, but people still decide its relevance, campaign direction and intended results. Speaking at DMWF North America 2026, Bethany Eppner, Vice President and Head of Global Business Marketing at Fandom, described the change: “AI is an amazing tool. What it does for marketers is that it actually makes us more directors and less producers.”

For Fandom, these decisions matter commercially because its work with fans and brand clients benefits when audience understanding leads to stronger engagement. Eppner’s description also gives practical meaning to growing corporate interest in agentic technology, AI that can carry out tasks with some autonomy, while keeping human creativity central. Easier production gives marketers more capacity to oversee the purpose, consistency and effect of what they make.

Widespread adoption raises the question of business impact

The scale of AI adoption makes that oversight relevant across many businesses. The UK government’s AI Adoption Research puts the share of businesses actively using AI at 72% and identifies marketing and administration as the functions using it most. This measures businesses overall; ISBA’s 2026 survey examines UK advertisers and their use of generative AI, the category of AI used to create content. The two populations offer separate views of adoption.

Among those advertisers, ISBA found that 99% of respondents worked with generative AI, while 14% reported a substantial impact on business results. Widespread use therefore leaves a management question open: what does the business gain from deploying the technology? Answering requires a clear objective, because producing work faster and improving marketing results measure different kinds of progress.

Efficiency was the primary goal of AI strategies for 75% of ISBA respondents. Efficiency means reducing the time, effort or resources needed to do work, so faster content creation can deliver a direct production benefit. Completing the same work with fewer resources frees capacity. Whether that capacity improves campaign planning or audience understanding depends on how the team uses it.

Effectiveness concerns whether marketing achieves its intended result, and ISBA found that businesses focused on improving effectiveness were twice as likely to report meaningful impact. So assessing an AI strategy’s contribution requires understanding its objective. The survey’s finding about meaningful impact is a separate measure from substantial impact on business results. Leaders therefore need to specify the improvement they expect and assess production gains and marketing outcomes separately.

Okoone experts
LET'S TALK!

A project in mind?
Schedule a 30-minute meeting with us.

Senior experts helping you move faster across product, engineering, cloud & AI.

Please enter a valid business email address.

Individual assets need a shared campaign purpose

Assessing marketing outcomes means looking at how assets work together across a campaign. Consider a hypothetical set of AI-generated posts and emails: each may sound persuasive on its own, yet together they may communicate different purposes or inconsistent messages. An audience encountering them receives a weaker overall brand message. Reviewing each asset individually leaves the campaign’s coherence unchecked.

Faster production increases the amount of work that may need this broader review. Easier generation gives a team more options, but someone who understands the business must decide which ideas serve the campaign. That selection starts with a strategy that gives posts and emails a shared purpose. Setting the purpose before production gives marketers a way to assess polished content beyond how convincing it sounds.

The same purpose guides execution, when marketers must spot work that has drifted from the intended direction and decide how to correct it. Eppner’s shift toward directing brings this responsibility forward: people select ideas, maintain consistency and remain accountable for outcomes. Production speed creates value when marketers use it within that direction, and the resulting work still needs review as part of the whole campaign.

Audience analysis informs the choice of response

Choosing a relevant campaign direction requires understanding the people who will encounter it. At Fandom, Eppner described using AI to interpret billions of signals from fans, extending its role into audience analysis. She said that work includes spotting rapidly developing trends, anticipating interests that may emerge next and investigating what motivates fans. Faster interpretation gives marketers more information to guide their response.

Turning those findings into a response still requires judgment about what an interest means to its audience. Eppner described that understanding as a condition of connection: “You have to understand the audience and their passions, and only then will you be able to really connect with the fans.” In her account, recognizing a pattern helps marketers consider an opportunity; understanding why people care helps them decide how to act on it.

Acting on that understanding brings a different responsibility from analyzing the signals. Eppner draws the distinction directly: “Yes, AI is important in terms of diving into the data and understanding what drives fans and kind of all the signals we get and interpreting those. But when it comes to actually interacting with fans, it’s human to human.” Her account places AI in the analytical work and people in the relationship with fans.

Automated interaction can put trust at risk

That relationship is where Eppner sees a risk from excessive automation. Reducing manual effort in routine work can give marketers more time for fans, but automating the interaction itself can weaken the connection that work is meant to support. Her warning is direct: “If you throw AI into that and it’s too automated, you lose that connection.” The concern is whether the interaction conveys an understanding of the person receiving it.

Consumer research by Klaviyo and Datalily examines a separate audience response: trust after encountering visible AI-generated content. Both companies have a commercial interest in businesses’ marketing decisions, giving their research a stake in how brands use AI. They found that 31% of respondents lost trust after such an encounter, while 7% reported greater trust in a brand. For those reporting a loss, the effect reached their judgment of the brand itself.

These findings concern visible AI-generated content, while Eppner’s warning concerns the experience of interacting with a brand. AI-assisted analysis behind the scenes is a different use, and the consumer percentages describe respondents across the research rather than a particular group of fans. Keeping these distinctions clear helps marketers assess each use on its own terms: what the audience encounters, what it communicates and how people respond.

Saved production time creates room for relationship work

For fans who expect a brand to understand their interests, more frequent messaging can leave that expectation unmet if the messages fail to convey understanding. The capacity gained through faster production therefore creates a choice about where marketers spend their time. They can give more attention to interpreting audience interests and shaping interactions for fans and brand clients. Human involvement still requires sound decisions, but it gives someone responsibility for the experience.

Eppner connects that relationship work to the commercial return Fandom and its brand clients seek: “The fans need to know that you understand what they’re passionate about. And if you understand it, the fans will respect your messaging. And they will react to it in a positive way. So that’s really where we see the growth, and that’s where brands will see ROI.” ROI means return on investment; in her account, it follows from fans recognizing that a brand understands what matters to them.

Key takeaways for leaders

  • Direct the work: AI shifts marketers toward setting campaign direction, selecting ideas and overseeing results. Marketing heads need clear ownership of these decisions as production becomes easier.
  • Measure business impact separately: ISBA found that 99% of surveyed UK advertisers used generative AI, while 14% reported a substantial impact on business results. Marketing leaders need separate measures for production efficiency and campaign effectiveness.
  • Review campaign coherence: Individually persuasive AI-generated assets can send inconsistent messages when combined. Campaign owners need to set a shared purpose before production and review how posts, emails and other assets work together.
  • Turn audience signals into decisions: Fandom uses AI to interpret fan signals, identify emerging trends and explore motivations. Marketers remain responsible for deciding what those findings mean and how to respond.
  • Protect trust in audience interactions: Research by Klaviyo and Datalily found that 31% of respondents lost trust after encountering visible AI-generated content. Brand owners need to assess audience-facing automation separately from behind-the-scenes analysis.
  • Reinvest saved time in relationships: Faster production frees capacity for understanding audiences and shaping relevant interactions. Marketing heads can direct that capacity toward relationship work and assess whether it improves engagement and commercial outcomes.

Alexander Procter

November 16, 2026

7 Min

Okoone experts
LET'S TALK!

A project in mind?
Schedule a 30-minute meeting with us.

Senior experts helping you move faster across product, engineering, cloud & AI.

Please enter a valid business email address.