Gen Z’s AI adoption leaves retailers accountable for the experience
Gen Z’s willingness to shop with AI gives retailers a reason to look more closely at how they use it. A shopper can accept an AI recommendation and still object to how a brand uses the technology. Retailers investing in personalisation, automated customer service and product recommendations therefore face two separate questions: whether customers use these systems, and whether the experience earns their trust.
These questions matter because commercial goals can encourage brands to mistake technological familiarity for acceptance. Mark Ritson, founder of MiniMBA and a former marketing professor, challenges that assumption; his marketing education business also benefits from demand for guidance on these decisions. “There’s a tendency to assume that because Gen Z loves technology, they’ll tolerate anything brands do with it. The data suggests the opposite. They’re embracing AI rapidly, but they’re also proving to be the least forgiving when brands get it wrong.”
Gen Z is already using AI to make purchasing decisions
The purchasing figures show why retailers need to take that distinction seriously. SAP Engagement Cloud surveyed 2,000 UK consumers for Gen Z shopping habits reveal a growing trust gap and found that 48% of Gen Z respondents had bought a product recommended by AI, compared with 26% overall. The overall sample includes Gen Z, so the comparison shows stronger uptake among younger shoppers than across the full survey population. As a marketing-technology provider, SAP Engagement Cloud has a commercial interest in retailers investing in AI-led customer engagement.
A recommendation leaves the shopper responsible for completing the transaction, while an assistant that buys on their behalf takes on more responsibility. In SAP Engagement Cloud’s survey, 37% of Gen Z respondents said they would be willing to trust AI assistants to purchase for them. Across the full sample, 23% were comfortable letting assistants buy products and services on their behalf. These responses describe willingness to delegate a transaction, whereas the recommendation figures describe purchases already made.
Before delegation comes reliance on advice, which the survey measured separately. Across the full sample, 23% said they regularly trusted AI assistants and tools to help with buying decisions. That measure concerns help with a choice; authorising an assistant to complete a purchase transfers more control. Retailers need to distinguish these behaviours when deciding how much responsibility to give an AI system.
Sara Richter, chief marketing officer at SAP Engagement Cloud, interprets this pattern as rapid generational uptake. “Gen Z isn’t rejecting AI. They’re embracing it faster than any other generation and increasingly allowing it to influence what they buy. The surprise is that greater adoption does not translate into greater tolerance.” Richter brings the question back to what happens after customers begin using AI: they continue to judge the retailer’s conduct.
That judgment now takes place in a buying process where AI can compete with personal advice. In SAP Engagement Cloud’s survey, almost a quarter of respondents said they were more likely to use AI recommendations than advice from friends and family. Word of mouth has long helped shoppers decide which products deserve consideration; individually filtered rankings and tailored suggestions now play a similar role. For retailers, this adds another influence to understand before the final purchase.
As AI moves from marketing experiments into everyday buying, these influences make attribution, the task of identifying what contributed to a sale, more difficult. Generational differences already shape product discovery, research and purchasing, while changing retail habits add further variation. A completed transaction may follow automated advice, a tailored ranking or delegated purchasing, so the transaction record alone reveals little about the decisions that preceded it.
A project in mind?
Schedule a 30-minute meeting with us.
Senior experts helping you move faster across product, engineering, cloud & AI.
Reported brand switching makes implementation a commercial concern
The consequences extend beyond how a sale happens to whether the retailer keeps the customer. Among Gen Z respondents in SAP Engagement Cloud’s survey, 43% reported moving to other brands because of particular AI use. These respondents connected AI use to a change in their buying behaviour, making the quality of an implementation a customer-retention concern.
The switching result also gives commercial weight to Ritson’s distinction between familiarity and tolerance. A shopper may welcome AI-assisted product research while rejecting a retailer’s use of the technology elsewhere in the experience. Retailers therefore need to examine when customers accept assistance and when they want a different response. The survey’s findings on human support, privacy and transparency identify several such situations.
Human support becomes particularly relevant when shopping gets difficult. In SAP Engagement Cloud’s survey, 37% of Gen Z respondents said they preferred human assistance when complications arose. Choosing a product and resolving a problem create different needs, so enthusiasm for automated recommendations can coexist with a preference for personal help. Customer-service leaders need to understand what shoppers consider complicated and whether they can reach a person at that point.
Alongside access to help, shoppers judge how retailers handle their information. In SAP Engagement Cloud’s survey, 32% of Gen Z respondents identified data privacy and security as important. Willingness to use a recommendation tool can therefore sit alongside concern about the information it uses. Retailers assessing acceptance need to understand how customers view those data practices as part of the experience.
Customers also want to understand how AI affects the choices presented to them. SAP Engagement Cloud found that 29% of Gen Z respondents wanted greater clarity about AI-driven decisions, while around 25% said undisclosed or non-transparent AI use would cause them to lose loyalty to a brand. The first finding expresses a desire for explanation; the second describes an anticipated response to a lack of openness. Both give retailers a reason to make AI’s role clear, even when the interaction itself feels easy.
Richter connects that expectation to customer retention: “Gen Z is willing to trust AI with recommendations and even purchasing decisions, but they expect brands to be transparent about how it is used. Brands that fail to earn that trust risk losing customers just as quickly as they gain them.” Her warning concerns the commercial consequences of how brands deploy AI. The survey records both reported switching over particular AI use and stated expectations about transparency, which retailers should examine as separate customer responses.
AI can strengthen loyalty when it improves the experience
Customers’ judgments can also work in a retailer’s favour. In SAP Engagement Cloud’s survey, 15% of Gen Z respondents said they were more loyal to brands when AI improved their shopping experience. A further finding concerns personalised marketing: 21% said it strengthened their brand loyalty. Both results connect loyalty to a benefit the shopper experiences, whether through better shopping or more relevant communication.
The conditions attached to those benefits matter when teams assess an investment. Individually tailored messages create value when customers find them useful, and an automated interaction helps when it improves the task they are trying to complete. The positive and negative percentages answer different questions, so subtracting them would give a misleading measure of AI’s overall effect. They also describe responses among Gen Z respondents rather than successive stages in one customer’s journey.
Retailers need to investigate the experience behind adoption
To understand those different responses, retail teams need to connect business measures with customer experience. Usage records interaction with a system, conversion records a purchase, and retention records whether customers continue buying. Each answers a useful business question, while customer research can explain how shoppers understood the AI involved and what affected their trust. Together, these measures help teams distinguish a used system from a useful experience.
The survey gives teams specific questions to investigate. Do shoppers understand when and how AI influences recommendations and decisions, and how does that understanding affect their choices? How do customers view the retailer’s handling of privacy and security? When a shopping task becomes complicated, can they get the human help they want? These questions connect implementation decisions to the situations respondents identified.
The same investigation needs to examine the benefit the retailer intends to provide. Teams can ask whether AI measurably improves relevance or makes shopping easier, then compare those findings with usage, conversion and retention reports. Automating an interaction changes the process, but understanding its value requires attention to the customer’s task. A convenient research tool, for example, may earn repeated use without creating broader confidence in the brand.
Customer research can reveal that distinction, provided researchers examine their own assumptions. Their experiences shape how they interpret behaviour, which can lead them to read frequent AI use as confidence in the retailer. Real-time observation offers a way to investigate the difference by watching consumers interact with AI systems. Researchers can see when shoppers accept recommendations, seek explanations or look for another form of help, and ask what prompted the change.
To guide that inquiry, SAP Engagement Cloud offers three characteristics as context for Gen Z behaviour: digital familiarity, social consciousness and financial consciousness. These give researchers starting points for questions about individuals. Using them as a ready-made profile would risk replacing observation with assumptions.
Digital familiarity helps explain why shoppers can readily turn to AI-assisted discovery and research. SAP Engagement Cloud describes Gen Z as “digital natives”, having grown up with internet access present for almost all their lives. That experience can make new tools feel familiar enough to try. Whether shoppers approve of a particular use still depends on the experience a brand creates.
Beyond familiarity with technology, SAP Engagement Cloud describes Gen Z as generally more socially conscious than older generations. It associates that outlook with attention to how brands use technology and communicate their values. Researchers can explore how those concerns enter a purchase decision and which brand actions matter to an individual shopper. This gives the broad characteristic a practical role in customer research.
Financial consciousness, another characteristic identified by SAP Engagement Cloud, introduces a reason to use AI, particularly among older Gen Z members who think carefully about purchases. AI-assisted discovery, research and decision support can appeal to shoppers managing a budget because they help people consider what to buy. Retailers can investigate which forms of assistance help customers make those decisions, while asking about individual circumstances rather than inferring income or access from budget awareness.
Main highlights
- Separate recommendation use from purchase delegation: SAP Engagement Cloud’s survey of 2,000 UK consumers found that 48% of Gen Z respondents had bought an AI-recommended product, while 37% were willing to let AI purchase for them. Retail product teams need to assess these behaviours separately when deciding how much control to give AI.
- Treat AI implementation as a retention concern: Among Gen Z respondents, 43% reported switching brands because of particular AI use. Retail and customer-service teams need to investigate how transparency, data privacy and access to human help affect customers’ responses.
- Tie investment to customer benefit: AI that improved shopping strengthened loyalty for 15% of Gen Z respondents, while personalised marketing strengthened loyalty for 21%. Product and marketing teams can evaluate investments against measurable improvements in relevance and ease of shopping.
- Connect performance measures with customer research: Usage, conversion and retention each capture a different business outcome. Customer researchers can pair those measures with observation to establish when shoppers accept AI advice, seek explanations or turn to human support.
A project in mind?
Schedule a 30-minute meeting with us.
Senior experts helping you move faster across product, engineering, cloud & AI.


